Making a Silk Purse out of a Sow’s Ear


October 12, 2014 by bluenosebible

By Tom Giles

The whole ownership issue surrounding Birmingham City has been reported widely in the local media, although unfortunately not to a large extent in the national press and still nobody knows what is going on. What has been happening to the club in the last few years is arguably the worst situation regarding ownership in English football and, despite constant murmurings of takeovers and even an official green light for one consortium, there seems to be no sign of progress. However, we have heard all this before and I would rather not dwell on it.

Nikola-Zigic-007I would rather write about the somewhat strange advantages of being in such a predicament. The first of these is the financial situation. At Birmingham we no longer have players who, in football terms, are on a ridiculous amount of money. The financial mess surrounding Birmingham City means that the wage bill has had to be continually slashed with the maximum wage now offered to a new player at the club being around the £5,000 p/w mark, with Clayton Donaldson the only player reportedly on more. It is refreshing to see footballers on more modest wages and hopefully this sensible attitude regarding pay can continue after the ownership farce is over. This hopefully means we will no longer pay players more than they are worth. When people read that they will inevitably think of Nikola Zigic who was earning £60k a week in the Championship. This was far more than he was worth and a lot of people blamed the Serb for earning this amount of money and demanded that he defer his wages in order to help the club. However, I think that is harsh. It was not his fault that the board were foolish enough to offer him such a large contract without a clause to reduce his wages in the case of relegation. Hopefully lessons have now been learned and contracts will be managed better in future meaning players will be on more modest wages.

A further advantage is the emergence of young talent. In the last couple of seasons we have seen the likes of Nathan Redmond, Jack Butland, Callum Reilly, Mitch Hancox, Demarai Gray, Reece Brown, Koby Arthur and Will Packwood play regularly for the first team. Some of these players are local lads and Bluenoses who constantly try their best for the team and the shirt. Even if some of these players do not support the club as a fan they realise they have a fantastic opportunity to play regular football and have grown a fondness for the club after spending so long in its ranks. If we were not in the situation we are in now, these players would more than likely have been sold on or left to rot in the reserves. The whole point of a football club is that it is a community asset and, quite frankly, there is nothing better than seeing players from the community representing the local area in a national or international competition. In a way I have enjoyed watching Birmingham more in recent times for this reason rather than when we were in the Premier League when there was less of a local connection. The quality of football may not be as high but you can feel the passion for the club not just in the stands but also on the pitch. This could also really benefit Blues in the future as it will teach us that our academy is good enough to produce talent. With this being the case, we will not always have to spend silly money on average players when we have players at the club who are capable of making a difference.

Unfortunately, due to the current financial burden on the club we may see the youth players who are currently in the first team go the same way as Nathan Redmond and Jack Butland. However, hopefully when this ownership farce is over, we will not forget the joys that we have had watching young, local players who are committed to the shirt and to playing for Birmingham City. Hopefully, if this happens the club will continue the idea of bringing academy products into the first team set up.

_38950775_dugarry203Arguably the most important advantage, touched upon in the previous point, is the community feel around the club. When we were in the ‘glory days’ of the Premier League we were lucky enough to see the likes of Christophe Dugarry and Mikael Forssell strut their stuff at St. Andrews. However, with this current crisis surrounding the club, it feels as if fans can really see the value of the football club as a community asset and perhaps we took the club itself for granted during the Premier League years. Unfortunately it seems we preferred the lure of supporting a Premier League team rather than the football club itself, but we now realise how important the club is to our lives. I remember being devastated when Blues got relegated from the top flight in May 2011 but this whole idiocy surrounding the club at the moment has made me realise that there’s far more to football than promotion and relegation. In fact, the joy of football is about being able to go and see your club every week, no matter the division.

I think this is an appropriate point to insert a quote from the great Sir Bobby Robson:

What is a club in any case?

Not the buildings or the directors or the people who are paid to represent it.

It’s not the television contracts, get-out clauses, marketing departments or executive boxes.

It’s the noise, the passion, the feeling of belonging, the pride in your city.

It’s a small boy clambering up stadium steps for the very first time, gripping his father’s hand, gawping at that hallowed stretch of turf beneath him and, without being able to do a thing about it, falling in love.”

Obviously, the sooner the crisis is over with the better, but hopefully the above mentioned principles that have come out of this situation will remain at the club.

Keep Right On.


2 thoughts on “Making a Silk Purse out of a Sow’s Ear

  1. Alan Watton says:

    Great article if a little sentimental and there is nothing wrong with those sentiments. Our ‘great’ fans number about 14,000. There areprobably about three times that number who over the last 20 years have stopped coming. There are the its too expensive group who will never return. There are the ones that hated David Sullivan, Alex Mcleish, Carson Yeung , Peter Pannu, and now Lee Clarke. Well all bar the current manager they all have gone and not one penny of your money will be going into their pockets. The team is woefully underfunded and the only thing that is supporting that budget is the 14000. Were our gates to double the budget Blues would be able to afford a better time. A more vibrant club will be able to put out a better team and more importantly able to attract a serious owner. I believe the delay in selling is as much to do with the teams desperate plight than any Chinese politics. To put it simply get your back sides into those Blue and white seats and support the fans who do come and ARE the club.

  2. The Hong Kong stock exchange ruling body is the SFC ,which is an independent body ,they are bound by rules that protect share holders . .they are bound by rules such as
    They are there to promote understanding to the public of the operation of the SF industry
    And to protect the publics financial investments
    To minimise crime and misconduct in the financial market
    To reduce systemic risk in the securities in the industry
    And to assist the financial secretary in maintaining financial stability of Hong Kong by taking apt steps in relation to securities and future of industry …so if any blues fans with shares do not think that the SFC are not abiding by these rules then get together and put in a complaint

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


Next Match Special

Charity of Choice

Blues Collective Charity of Choice

Issue 300

%d bloggers like this: